If by flighty you mean, she keeps putting off your date, then you arent dating her. If instead you mean that shes constantly getting distracted by random butterflies, but the two of you are actually going on dates and enjoying each others company, at your age I would enjoy getting distracted by random butterflies with her.

But, you will be judged by every person around you on how you behave towards her. So whatever feelings you have, show only the best behaviors in your dealings with her. Shes the most beautiful, so your peers will be paying attention. If you decide that you dont want to date her because of whatever, then your honesty, kindness and care(or lack of any of these things) will be a big part of the story that people tell about you. If you only say good things about her, then other girls will be more open to idea of dating you. Being a guy that wont damage a reputation is a very important trait if you want to continue to date attractive popular women.

Did you fear what people may have thought when you were in love with the most beautiful girl in your school? I couldnt ask a girl out because…

How do I approach/get a beautiful girl in high school?

Why is it always hard to date that one very beautiful girl?

How do you ask a girl out on a date without breaking the current relationship (friendship)? I have a huge crush on this girl. I dont think sh…

Would you date a girl that is beautiful but has poor results at school?

Did you fear what people may have thought when you were in love with the most beautiful girl in your school? I couldnt ask a girl out because…

How do I approach/get a beautiful girl in high school?

Why is it always hard to date that one very beautiful girl?

How do you ask a girl out on a date without breaking the current relationship (friendship)? I have a huge crush on this girl. I dont think sh…

Would you date a girl that is beautiful but has poor results at school?

Have you ever dated a girl who is too beautiful?

Where did the most beautiful girl in your school end up?

Where is a great place to meet girls the summer after I graduated from high school? I want to meet girls not from my high school and not from …

What happened to the prettiest girl in your high school?

How can I know if a guy thinks Im hot, like what do guys like in middle school girls?

What is it like to be a beautiful girl that every boy wants?

How can I hangout with the pretty girls and get a pretty girlfriend in school?

Can a very very unattactive guy get to date a beautiful girl?

Would you rather be the prettiest girl in school or the most popular one?

Did you fear what people may have thought when you were in love with the most beautiful girl in your school? I couldnt ask a girl out because…

How do I approach/get a beautiful girl in high school?

Why is it always hard to date that one very beautiful girl?

How do you ask a girl out on a date without breaking the current relationship (friendship)? I have a huge crush on this girl. I dont think sh…

Would you date a girl that is beautiful but has poor results at school?

Have you ever dated a girl who is too beautiful?

Where did the most beautiful girl in your school end up?

Where is a great place to meet girls the summer after I graduated from high school? I want to meet girls not from my high school and not from …

What happened to the prettiest girl in your high school?